BLACK

03/12/06

Before development even started on BLACK, the team at Criterion came to the conclusion that they were going to mimic the most blast-happy Hollywood blockbusters with their new first-person shooter. By all accounts, they've succeeded in that goal. BLACK has big guns and bigger explosions. Loud booms and louder firefights. Lifeless enemies whose bodies fly a dozen feet in the air and bad guys who careen from catwalks with all the grace of a professional stuntman. But a funny thing happened on the way to their blockbuster: Criterion forgot to make a game that was actually fun to play. Don't get me wrong, BLACK has its redeeming qualities. As you read in our preview, the team wanted to let players "explore the world with bullets," and the final game lets you do that with such a destructive streak that it's hard not to laugh out loud and grin sadistically while blowing an enemy stronghold to kingdom come. But much like the Hollywood action films Criterion was trying to emulate, just because there are big battles in BLACK doesn't mean the final product is all that compelling. BLACK screenshot BLACK definitely has a narrative, and it's actually a rather good one. As a member of a black-ops team, you work your way through a series of flashbacks as your cutscene counterpart explains his actions to the lone government official who can save him from spending the rest of his life in prison. Criterion is clearly proud of its story, because there's no way to skip the between-level cutscenes, but when the presentation is this Hollywood-esque, it's easy to forgive the level-loading trick. But once the cutscene ends and you're actually playing each level, it's painfully obvious that BLACK is Criterion's debut first-person shooter. Without a doubt, BLACK is a great first outing for a developer experimenting with a genre. But when that first outing happens to appear in the most popular videogame genre, its shortcomings stand out like a bright red fuel tank next to a moonlit tent. For instance, the enemy intelligence is to a large extent non-existent, as foes will somehow fail to hear grenades exploding 20 feet away from them, and although they are quick to take cover, once they emerge from their shelter they somehow forget where you were. The guns, too, are relatively ineffective, as it takes 18 (or more) point-blank shots from an AK-47 to drop someone. I realize BLACK is all about mass destruction and clip-emptying battles, but that's a bit ridiculous. BLACK screenshot The worst offense, though, and the one that showcases the game's inability to stand out from the crowded FPS pack, is its repetitive gameplay. Without fail, each level involves linear objectives that change during the course of the mission, and most of the objectives serve little a purpose other than to give you an excuse to blow-up more stuff. As odd as it sounds, the guns really are the main character in BLACK, which explains the compulsion to use them to destroy every part of the environment. But after a few levels, the blowing-up of stuff starts to get boring. After all, even the best Hollywood action flicks don't go for more than two hours. At least the game looks good, although for some reason it looks more jaw-dropping on the PS2 than it does the Xbox. In both versions the environments are diverse (and absolutely huge), and the explosions are remarkable in their detail and splash damage. But the details within each environment, while good, repeat many times, and the stereotype of carbon-copied enemies rings true with five basic enemy types. In terms of other first-person shooters on the PS2, BLACK looks great. But compared with some of the other recent FPS games on Xbox, most notably Far Cry Instincts, BLACK looks somewhat pedestrian. BLACK screenshot One graphical touch, the blur effect when reloading guns, was an ingenious move on Criterion's part. If you're reloading a gun in real life, your attention would be focused on the gun, not necessarily the enemies around you. The blur effect, then, makes perfect sense as it tries to imitate your blurred peripheral vision when watching the enemies. Unfortunately, the blur effect is a bit too heavy-handed, and it actually made me queasy after a while because it was so disorienting. Had it been toned down, it could have been one of the best introductions BLACK made to the FPS genre. BLACK screenshot Criterion wanted to shake up the genre and offer something new, but in the end, BLACK plays just like any other average first-person shooter. Except that it doesn't have a multiplayer mode. BLACK is a good first outing, but it just doesn't seem to offer much more than a few more booms and exploding barrels. And we already have enough of those to go around.
Gameplay: 7.5
The ability to blow everything up is great, but the actual gameplay is your standard FPS fare.
Graphics: 9 [PS2], 8 [Xbox]
Again, explosions look great. Overall, the PS2 version looks better than most games on that system, but the Xbox version isn't quite as hot.
Sound: 7.8
It's loud. And, um, loud. Things go boom, and they sound loud. Need we say more? Voiceovers and music are average.
Replay: 5
Blowing stuff up is a blast (pardon the pun), but eventually you'll want to move on. Not having multiplayer is a liability.
Overall: 7.5
Taken as a whole, BLACK is just your average first-person shooter, so an average score is what it gets.
-- Jonas Allen
Send News to N4G | | Slashdot It!

Most Recent Features

In-Game Ads Finally Done Right: Rainbow Six Vegas 2

Rainbow Six Vegas 2 is getting a campaign for Tropic Thunder, the first effective use of the medium.

EA's Big Changes -- That Nobody Even Notices

As we begin an on-location visit to Electronic Arts, we wonder just how big the industry truly is.

Overlord: Raising Hell Review

Bossing around minions on the PS3 doesn't get old, but the "improvements" just cover up lingering issues.

ESA Evaluating Major Changes for E3 2009

Changes are always considered, but this year's post-show survey shows some biggies in the air.

DailyGame's Best of E3 2008 Awards

The competition this year was somewhat slim, but it was very tight. Here are the best of the best.

DailyGame's PlayStation Homepage

In-Game Ads Finally Done Right: Rainbow Six Vegas 2

Rainbow Six Vegas 2 is getting a campaign for Tropic Thunder, the first effective use of the medium.

EA's Big Changes -- That Nobody Even Notices

As we begin an on-location visit to Electronic Arts, we wonder just how big the industry truly is.

Wolf of the Battlefield: Commando 3 Review

Full of explosions, guns and huge bosses, but nothing so amazing that you'll be clamoring for it.

ESA Evaluating Major Changes for E3 2009

Changes are always considered, but this year's post-show survey shows some biggies in the air.

DailyGame's Best of E3 2008 Awards

The competition this year was somewhat slim, but it was very tight. Here are the best of the best.

DailyGame's Xbox 360 Homepage

EA's Big Changes -- That Nobody Even Notices

As we begin an on-location visit to Electronic Arts, we wonder just how big the industry truly is.

ESA Evaluating Major Changes for E3 2009

Changes are always considered, but this year's post-show survey shows some biggies in the air.

DailyGame's Best of E3 2008 Awards

The competition this year was somewhat slim, but it was very tight. Here are the best of the best.

Space Invaders Extreme Review

The five-stage game has some nice updates for a storied franchise, making this a worthy chapter.

Most Disappointing Games of E3 2008

E3 may have ended, but developers still have plenty of work ahead -- especially on these games.

DailyGame's Nintendo Homepage

The Exorcism of Emily Rose (Unrated) Blu-ray Review

The mix of courtroom drama and horror film is surprisingly good, and the A/V aspects hold up well.

Batman: Gotham Knight Blu-ray Review

Its six episodes are too disparate, too short and animated too differently for a truly compelling experience.

The Ruins Unrated Version Blu-ray Disc Review

It's got all the stereotypical teens and blood you need, but it starts too slowly and has serious plot deficiencies.

Earth: The Biography Blu-ray Review

The BBC once again strikes documentary gold, but a thesis and A/V issues seem more like iron pyrite.

Stargate Continuum Blu-ray Disc Review

The cast reunion is nice and story is good, but a few plot holes and inconsistent VFX are disappointing.

DailyGame's Blu-ray Homepage

Actiontec Mega Plug AV Powerline Gaming Kit Review

Getting a wired connection through your home's electrical wiring couldn't be easier or more secure.

3K RazorBook 400 Mini Notebook PC Review

This could be a blogger's best friend, at least for basic functions.

D-BOX: How and Why Home Theater is Evolving

You may think Star Tours-like seating is not for home, but it's closer than you think.

Skullcrushers Subwoofer Headphones Review

The name may be brutal, but if you're into bass, this is one refined headset.

National Treasure 2: Book of Secrets Blu-ray Review

Nicolas Cage rocks Mount Rushmore, and the movie itself is rockin' too.

DailyGame's Home Electronics Homepage